I saw a knight in a shining armor
Walked into the bar that night
Blue jeans, ball cap, and a Carhartt
Looks different under neon lights
All that time, my eyes were playing tricks on me
But tonight, I'm alright, now that I can see

In my mind, you were mine, you were good, you were kind
You and me we were so in love
In my head, you were him, you were right, you were it
But it wasn't what I thought it was
You never gave me your best
But my heart filled in the rest
I'm not getting over you, that isn't hard to do
I'm getting over who my mind's made up

Thought I'd be brokenhearted, the next time I saw you here
A cowboy riding in with a cigarette
Was nothing, but smoke and mirrors
I hate to say, it was never you

'Cause in my mind you were mine, you were good, you were kind
You and me we were so in love
In my head, you were him, you were right, you were it
But it wasn't what I thought it was
You never gave me your best
But my heart filled in the rest
I'm not getting over you, that isn't hard to do
I'm getting over who my mind's made up

My mind's made up

You can't get back what you never had
Seeing you now, yea, it ain't so bad
'Cause you can't get back what you never had

Yeah, in my mind, you were mine, you were good, you were kind
You and me we were so in love
In my head you were him, you were right, you were it
But it wasn't what I thought it was
You never gave me your best, but my heart filled in the rest
I'm not getting over you, that isn't hard to do
I'm getting over who my mind's made up

Yeah, I'm getting over who my mind's made up